Injunctions In Contract Disputes - Overall Justice Prevails
In a guideline decision, the Court of Appeal has ruled that the requirements of overall justice can sometimes trump the long-established principle that, in contract disputes, injunctions to restrain threatened breaches will only be granted where dama
Arizona (I-Newswire) April 30, 2014 -
In a guideline decision, the Court of Appeal has ruled that the requirements of overall justice can sometimes trump the long-established principle that, in contract disputes, injunctions to restrain threatened breaches will only be granted where damages would not be an adequate remedy.
The proprietors of a trading software package (company A) had sought to terminate the licence of company B to market the product in the Middle East. Company B had, pending arbitration, applied for an injunction restraining withdrawal of the licence, upon which its entire livelihood depended.
In refusing to grant such an injunction, the High Court found that, notwithstanding the fact that company B would be put out of business by the termination of its licence, damages would be an adequate remedy.
In allowing company Bs appeal and granting the injunction sought, the Court of Appeal noted that the contract between the parties included a clause which limited the damages that would be payable by company A in the event of a breach. Amongst other things, the clause precluded company B from seeking compensation for its lost profits.
The Court noted that the primary obligation of the parties was to perform the contract and that the requirement to pay damages in the event of a breach was secondary. An agreement to restrict the recoverability of damages in the event of a breach could not be viewed as an agreement to excuse performance of the primary obligation.
Noting that it could not be just for contracting parties to be able to walk away from their commitments with impunity, the Court observed. The rule, if rule is the right word, that an injunction should not be granted where damages would be an adequate remedy should be applied in a way which reflects the substantial justice of the situation.
Giving guidance for the future, the Court concluded, where a party to a contract stipulates that, if he breaches his obligations, his liability will be limited or the damages he must pay will be capped, that is a circumstance which in justice tends to favour the grant of an injunction to prohibit the breach in the first place.
ABOUT SERENITY LAWSerenity Law is a London-based commercial law firm like no other. We offer an innovative alternative to the existing conventional solutions. Instead of employing your own full-time, in-house lawyer or consulting a law practice, with Serenity Law you get legal advice when you like, as often as you like and for as long (or as short) as you like. Serenity provides top quality legal services at affordable prices. Serenity Law delivers commercial and dispute resolution legal services to London, UK and international clients. Practice areas are Corporate Law, Commercial Property, Real Estate and Property Litigation, Employment Law and Intellectual Property
About SEO Samba
SEO Samba is a web marketing software as a service platform where websites are built to increase per More..formances with search engines. SEO Samba automatically executes search engine optimization techniques, and market products & services to an ever increasing number of free Internet marketing websites, directories, and search engines.
Ideal for small businesses, and ecommerce merchants, Samba can also be private labeled by directories, certified marketing representatives, SEO firms and Web agencies. For more information about SEO Samba, visit http://www.seosamba.com or contact firstname.lastname@example.org, and in the US: +(1 ) 877.450-9894 or in Europe at +(33) 675637635Less..
2140 S Dupont Highway
Phone : (877) 450.9894
Tags:Software contract justice commercial litigation damages licence liability evidence injunction commercial rents community trade mark court of appeal Civil Procedure rules commercial law firm uk
Published in:Legal / Law
Published On:April 30, 2014
Print Release:Print Release
If you have questions regarding information in this press release contact the company listed above. I-Newswire.com is a press release service and not the author of this press release.The information that is on or available through this site is for informational purposes only and speaks only as of the particular date or dates of that information. As some companies and PR Agencies submit their press releases once per week,month or quarter, make sure to check the official company website for accurate release dates as our site displays the I-Newswire.com press release distribution date only.We do not guarantee the accuracy or completeness of information on or available through this site, and we are not responsible for or omissions in that information or for actions taken in reliance on that information.